Potsy Pizza, located at 5925 Tilghman St in Allentown, PA, is quickly becoming a local favorite for pizza enthusiasts. The establishment is not just known for its mouthwatering pizzas but also for the warm and friendly atmosphere created by its staff. Customers like Mike Mengel rave about both the culinary creations and the customer service, emphasizing that the pizza stands up to New York style comparisons—a testament to its quality.
Reviewers like Bill Grant highlight the prompt delivery and range of menu options, from their meat lovers pan pizza to delicious baked ziti and cheeseburgers, showcasing a diverse array of flavors. Although some dishes, like the ziti, may need a touch more sauce, the consensus remains that the food is tasty and well-portioned. The standout, according to numerous reviews, is the gentle attentiveness of the staff and the inviting ambiance of the restaurant.
Potsy Pizza has certainly carved a niche in the pizza landscape of Pennsylvania, and with its combination of great food and exceptional service, it’s no wonder patrons are eager to return. The overwhelming love from the community reflects the genuinely satisfying experience that awaits with every slice.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Has table service
Amenities
Has toilet
Has Wi-Fi
Free Wi-Fi
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Good for groups
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Potsy Pizza
Mike Mengel
Jul 2,2025
The guys who run this kitchen, and everybody you see behind the counters, are the nicest people around, but also make some of the best food I’ve ever had. Some of these reviews knock them for other people comparing their pizza to NY style... well, their food is that good that people WILL make that comparison. Amazing food. Amazing staff. 10 out of 10. Thanks for everything you guys do!
Bill Grant
Jun 25,2025
Great place. Ordered delivered under 40min. 18 pan pizza meat lovers was great good flavor good amount of sauce. Also had Bake Ziti with salad & cheeseburger deluxe with fries. The ziti was a bit dry for me but did taste very good. I like sauce so thats on me. Lol but the burger amazed me the most good portions good flavor & the bun was there right where it's supposed to be close to the end. Bun not dried rock hard or not soggy. Y'all get kudos for that. I will come back potty pizza. Thanks
Zina Blackwell
Jun 16,2025
We are in town for the greatest antique truck show in the world , wanted something to eat and the hotel recommended Patsy's special. We got the 14 inch Patsys special. Pretty good ! They deliver also . We will probably order again while here.
Bless Carriers
Jun 2,2025
Absolutely love this place!!! This is by far the best pizza I’ve tasted in all of PA. The staff are extremely friendly and courteous.
Ruth Howard
May 24,2025
The menu is huge! The pizza was good! The workers were very nice!
Dave Stout
Apr 22,2025
I want u to know that, for 30 years I have NEVER got a "PERFECT ORDER" (from U or anyone else before), Until this order. I don't give 5 star ratings because there's alway room for improvement. BUT! I must tell u that (even thought I only live 2 miles way and I should expect this quality on every order) that this was without a DOUBT "the BEST" food quality for take out service EVER! These steak sandwichs were "piping" hot from the grill because when I bit into the sandwich the inside burnt my mouth . NO SHIT! a perfect delivery. the fries were also pefectly done and I had my doubts ordering from u the 4th time only to get another soggy fry order. NOT THIS TIME! It was a "perfect storm" u created. super hot steak sandwiches along with perfectly crispy fries. I've been ordering from I for years and years and NEVER, EVER GOT a perfect order like this one.PERFECT I say. PS I cant post pictures because I ate must of this order, it was sheer perfection once in a life time (I hope not), sheer perfection. Dave C. Stout
The Apparition
Apr 3,2025
I've been a customer since the fall of 2015. My travels have carried me all over the country but I make it a point to stop here every chance I get because it's the best bowl of pasta money can buy. This is my go-to dish: Linguine with extra meat sauce, garlic bread and salad with Italian dressing. And tip 100% of the bill like I do, because quality needs to be rewarded.
Willie MCDANIEL
Mar 17,2025
Damion was our server. Great service. Favio was the cook. Everything tasted really good. Price was very reasonable. Definitely will be back. It’s a thumbs for us. Keep the doors open.
Reviews For Potsy Pizza